打印

有冇人知道 3 Commando Birgade 有新成員

SB_Douglas 一等士官帖子 270 積分 5356 Like 0 在線時間 51 小時註冊時間 7-1-2008 個人空間發短消息加為好友當前離線	1^# 大中小發表於 17-5-2008 17:58 只看該作者有冇人知道 3 Commando Birgade 有新成員有冇人知道 British Army 1 rifle batttalion 重新組合跟 3 commando Birgade 領導重新命名 Army Commando Nickname:2005 year (RM) Nickname:Since 2006 (SB) 司馬昭之心歇後語... 道聽途說力量有限親身體會大悟知堯
UID 4673 精華 0 威望 794 金錢 794 犯規 0 閱讀權限 20 最後登錄 4-7-2008 查看詳細資料	TOP

auxair

Rank: 8 資深士官長

帖子: 354
積分: 7988
Like: 0
在線時間: 476 小時
註冊時間: 19-5-2007

2^# 大中小發表於 17-5-2008 19:56 只看該作者

引用:

原帖由 SB_Douglas 於 17-5-2008 17:58 發表
有冇人知道 British Army 1 rifle batttalion 重新組合
跟 3 commando Birgade 領導重新命名
Army Commando

1 RIFLES
http://www.army.mod.uk/infantry/ ... /1_rifles/index.htm
is now a manoeuvring battalion under the order of battle of 3 Commando Bde
http://www.royal-marines.mod.uk/server/show/nav.6617,
but the latter is still under RM.

I understand that Army Commandos were all disbanded after WWII, and the role of amphibious assault was completely subsumed under RM. Before that, there were both Army and RM Commandos.

As for Army Commando, anybody still remember "The Longest Day" - Lord Lovat's commando linking up with Maj Howard's glider borne infantry (Ox & Buck)?

[ 本帖最後由 auxair 於 17-5-2008 20:20 編輯 ]

TOP

auxair

Rank: 8 資深士官長

帖子: 354
積分: 7988
Like: 0
在線時間: 476 小時
註冊時間: 19-5-2007

3^# 大中小發表於 25-5-2008 21:09 只看該作者

I stand corrected.

I just noticed today on some pictures of the Joint RAF/AAC/RM suport helicopter standards team that visited Hong Kong GFS a few months ago - two Army SNCOs wore a black on olive arc shape "Army Commando" shoulder title on both sleeves of their Soldier 95 DPM shirt, with the 3 Commando Bde TRF beneath it (and Para Wings in between by one of SNCO) on the upper right sleeve. One the upper left sleeve the line up was "ARMY COMMANDO", the miniature Union Jack, and the Commando Dagger. It may be the case that army personnel assigned to 3 Commando Bde and passed the Commando Course are now eligible to wear the insignia.

[ 本帖最後由 auxair 於 26-5-2008 01:32 編輯 ]

TOP

SB_Douglas

Rank: 6 一等士官

帖子: 270
積分: 5356
Like: 0
在線時間: 51 小時
註冊時間: 7-1-2008

4^# 大中小發表於 31-5-2008 23:29 只看該作者

引用:

原帖由 auxair 於 25-5-2008 21:22 發表
I stand corrected.

I just noticed today on some pictures of the Joint RAF/AAC/RM suport helicopter standards team that visited Hong Kong GFS a few months ago - two Army SNCOs wore a black on ...

I don't agreed it ,if they are wearning the Commando Dagger. It just say that the army personnel assigned to 3 Commando Bde, If they passed the Commando Course, it should be wearning the green beret.

Nickname:2005 year (RM)
Nickname:Since 2006 (SB)
司馬昭之心歇後語...

道聽途說力量有限
親身體會大悟知堯

TOP

auxair

Rank: 8 資深士官長

帖子: 354
積分: 7988
Like: 0
在線時間: 476 小時
註冊時間: 19-5-2007

5^# 大中小發表於 31-5-2008 23:50 只看該作者

Is HRH Prnce Andrew "army personnel assigned to Commando Cde"

I also have pics of Prince Andrew in RAF No 1 Service Dresss wearing the Commando Dagger

Let me cite an example, I've neither seen nor heard of any RAF Personnel who passed the All Arms Commando Course wear the Green Beret even if they are awarded with it but they surely wear the "Commando Dagger". They always wear the Air Force Blue-grey beret even when "Commando qualified". Mind you I personally know a few RAF Regiment personnel who wear the "Commando Dagger" but they just can't be members of the 3 Commando Bde, being on a Airfield Defence Squadron or assigned as instructors at the RAF College

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Arms_Commando_Course - what is on the last sentence of the 1st paragraph?

With due respect, IN THIS CASE I have full confidence in my knowledge gained from my service experience

(There are of course millions of things I don't know...)

Any reponse to the pic, Marine SB_Dougals?

[ 本帖最後由 auxair 於 1-6-2008 00:36 編輯 ]

TOP

jwlchan

Rank: 15 四級准尉

帖子: 1869
積分: 29238
Like: 0
在線時間: 636 小時
註冊時間: 4-11-2007

榮譽會員勛章

6^# 大中小發表於 31-5-2008 23:57 只看該作者

引用:

原帖由 SB_Douglas 於 31-5-2008 15:29 發表

I don't agreed it ,if they are wearning the Commando Dagger. It just say that the army personnel assigned to 3 Commando Bde, If they passed the Commando Course, it should be wearning the gree ...

During my time in the Army, (1971 to 1993) there were some soliders completed the Commando Training course and then they would entitle to wear the commando badge on the uniform. However, they are still army but commando trained.

TOP

SB_Douglas

Rank: 6 一等士官

帖子: 270
積分: 5356
Like: 0
在線時間: 51 小時
註冊時間: 7-1-2008

7^# 大中小發表於 1-6-2008 00:25 只看該作者

引用:

原帖由 jwlchan 於 1-6-2008 00:10 發表

During my time in the Army, (1971 to 1993) there were some soliders completed the Commando Training course and then they would entitle to wear the commando badge on the uniform. However, th ...

Thanks for info!
but i was saw the april Combat & Survival, said that the Army Commando is not need fully train & passed the Commando Course.

Nickname:2005 year (RM)
Nickname:Since 2006 (SB)
司馬昭之心歇後語...

道聽途說力量有限
親身體會大悟知堯

TOP

jwlchan

Rank: 15 四級准尉

帖子: 1869
積分: 29238
Like: 0
在線時間: 636 小時
註冊時間: 4-11-2007

榮譽會員勛章

8^# 大中小發表於 1-6-2008 00:41 只看該作者

引用:

原帖由 SB_Douglas 於 31-5-2008 16:25 發表

Thanks for info!
but i was saw the april Combat & Survival, said that the Army Commando is not need fully train & passed the Commando Course.

I don't know what is that about....May be this is the commando attachment so that they are the member of the commando but do not need to carry out the task as commando. However,as the picture you can see from Auxair that officer had pass the commando course but serving in the normal British Army unit.

TOP

auxair

Rank: 8 資深士官長

帖子: 354
積分: 7988
Like: 0
在線時間: 476 小時
註冊時間: 19-5-2007

9^# 大中小發表於 1-6-2008 00:51 只看該作者

引用:

原帖由 SB_Douglas 於 1-6-2008 00:39 發表

Thanks for info!
but i was saw the april Combat & Survival, said that the Army Commando is not need fully train & passed the Commando Course.

Not every Army personnel assigned to the 3 Commando Bde needs to pass the Commando Course, similar to the fact that not everyone assigned to the former 5 Airborne Bde or the current 16 Airmobile Bde needs to airborne qualified.

Any one assigned to 3 Commando Bde can wear the brigade's TRF (dagger in a square) on the upper right sleeve, but only those who passed the Commando Course can wear the "Commado Dagger" - the reversed triangle dagger badge on the upper left arm.

On posting to 3 Commado Bde as one of the brigade's battalions, 1 RIFLES soldiers are understandably "encouraged" to pass the Commando Course, but by no means the entire outfit will be commando qualified.

[ 本帖最後由 auxair 於 1-6-2008 18:29 編輯 ]

TOP

jwlchan 四級准尉帖子 1869 積分 29238 Like 0 在線時間 636 小時註冊時間 4-11-2007 個人空間發短消息加為好友當前離線	10^# 大中小發表於 1-6-2008 03:15 只看該作者回覆 #9 auxair 的帖子 There would be also a pay difference if you are commando qualified!
UID 4080 精華 0 威望 2611 金錢 2111 犯規 0 閱讀權限 60 最後登錄 11-5-2014 查看詳細資料	TOP

有冇人知道 3 Commando Birgade 有新成員

有冇人知道 3 Commando Birgade 有新成員

引用:

引用:

引用:

引用:

引用:

引用:

回覆 #9 auxair 的帖子