macross1911

四川地震....損款收據 換服務及貨品


由於 四川地震,

眼見 wargame界 不論 商店, game場 及個人 二手買賣等,

以 救災捐款名義 吸引各善長公益,

把收益 捐給 各慈善機構,

特發奇想,

我們可否打錢直接捐給慈善機構,

再以慈善捐款收據 換取 貨品或服務呢?

marcooo

可以

等同張銀紙由銀行出一樣，如何換領貨幣

問題係如何證明捐款收據是真，廣泛接受性係幾多。

RoyalMarine

引用:

原帖由 marcooo 於 25-5-2008 08:27 發表
可以

等同張銀紙由銀行出一樣，如何換領貨幣

問題係如何證明捐款收據是真，廣泛接受性係幾多。

我覺得可惜好多都講到明"扣除必要開支後, 將全數撥捐.....", 而唔係"收入全數撥捐....", 所以你唔可能收據當現金.

呢句說話可圈可點. 除非該服務/產品是生活經常性開支, 否則某程度上可能只係生意的招來, 因為有幾多個商戶會全數公開何為必要開支?

老實講, 我要捐$1000, 假設某服務成本$500, 點解我唔好好直接將果$1000直接交到慈善志願機構而係要將$1500甚至更多交到佢地手先扣除必要開支換取貨品/服務? 因為以上$500只是我假設的成本, 該服務/產品的成本可能是$1400, 那麼這次我消費$1500, 最後捐款只可能係我心目中的10%.

其實樓主問得好, 如果有心參與捐款既商戶, 應該標明義務提供服務/產品並全數撥捐又或者等額捐助等, 如果係呢類商戶, 捐款收據當現金都唔係無機會. 但畢竟香港始終係一個商業社會, 賺幾多捐幾多無人會知亦無人會理, 最緊要只係收入幾多同埋換取到幾多服務....

[ 本帖最後由 RoyalMarine 於 25-5-2008 11:47 編輯 ]

marcooo

拔拔兄

今日等我去買枝 慈善134a 先

RoyalMarine

引用:

原帖由 marcooo 於 25-5-2008 11:10 發表
拔拔兄

今日等我去買枝 慈善134a 先

你係咪啜少啖134會死呀? 否則我覺得你應該直接捐出果$40.:x

marcooo

旺角有間東東義賣 gas (好似有top gas，紅氣)

$9草一大枝 134a，買左枝 browning 就有得啜啦，佢餓左幾年啦

steveyue

引用:

原帖由 marcooo 於 25-5-2008 14:12 發表
旺角有間東東義賣 gas (好似有top gas，紅氣)

$9草一大枝 134a，買左枝 browning 就有得啜啦，佢餓左幾年啦

你捐左個$90佢la

29Commando

但義賣個價都貴過人

B20_hk

最怕有人魚目混珠



另外Marco兄果支是甚麼牌子?

RoyalMarine

引用:

原帖由 B20_hk 於 25-5-2008 22:45 發表
最怕有人魚目混珠



另外Marco兄果支是甚麼牌子?

老實講, 如果有心要捐錢又何需高調. 有心就夠.

乾脆將你手上的一疊現鈔到紅十字會或其他慈善機構的善款收集箱, 直接了當, 唔怕有魚目混珠, 亦理論上不會發出任何聲音.

B20_hk

當然，有些鋪頭可能志在清貨

RoyalMarine

引用:

原帖由 B20_hk 於 25-5-2008 22:58 發表
當然，有些鋪頭可能志在清貨

我捐既錢唔多, 但已經盡力而為, 不過如果真係可以囉住張捐款收據去呢 d 咁熱心既舖頭掃貨同慈善 wargame 場當現金打幾次免費wargame, 我同 d 災民都會好感激.

Sidan

You're donating, not buying a "Coupon" so you can exchange the same amount of merchandise.  It is very generous of you to donate when our countryman is in need, but why should ANY shops should reimburse your donation with free merchandise or free wargame or free anything?  

This earthquake shaken not only Xichang, but the whole country and the world.  Everyone is affected, everyone is trying to do something to help, and every little bits help!  You might have donated previously, but you might have help even MORE by buying a bottle of "airsoft gas" or BBs under charity sales.

I have no comment regarding charity sale after cost deduction.  But for charity sales WITHOUT "Cost Deduction", it means every single dollar you paid for that merchandise goes to charity organizations.  For the money you paid, as least you get something, but the shops donate all the money from that sale.

I am shocked and sad to see that anyone manage to see "evil" and negativity in shops and wargame venues' charity attempt to raise money for Xichang.  They're doing their part and here we're complaining and question other's good intension.

I know I will probably upset someone by publicly voice my opinion, but there is something way too wrong about the idea and even worst is, so many agree.

[ 本帖最後由 Sidan 於 31-5-2008 02:28 編輯 ]

RoyalMarine

引用:

原帖由 Sidan 於 31-5-2008 02:16 發表
You're donating, not buying a "Coupon" so you can exchange the same amount of merchandise.  It is very generous of you to donate when our countryman is in need, but why should ANY shops ...

Help, you have absolutely reversed the subject and the object man. That 's NOT what we donors REQUESTED!!! That's what any service provider/shop OFFER to the donors! Please MAKE IT CLEAR FIRST before you piss off here. All the donors at least can see how the money go directly to any charity organization and bypass any hands of businessmen.

EVEN OUR DONORS CAN MOVE FASTER THAN SUCH BUSINESSMEN. THEY CAN DONATE ALL THEIR PROFIT WITHOUT A NOISE OR ANNOUNCE IT AFTERWARDS. WELL, TELL ME AND ALL THE DONORS, WHAT 'S WRONG WITH!?

I know you might one of the boss. We had donated our money already WITHOUT any conditions. PLEASE help the victims but not according to the sales result of coming weeks.

[ 本帖最後由 RoyalMarine 於 31-5-2008 10:46 編輯 ]

Sidan

At where I work, my company match every dollar donation by the staff.  If I donate $100, my company donate $100.  Now, you may say something negative like "why can't the company just donate the money", "why make so much "noise"", or you may call it an advertisement gimmick, etc.

The way I see it, it is another way to encourage staff to donate.  It's a spirit, a movement to encourage everyone to help.  Just like shops doing their parts to help by offering charity sales.  I just can't see why should any shop OFFER to use your donation slip as money.  What you're saying completely defeat the spirit of "Charity Sales".

And how do you know businessman doesn't donate outside the shop, out of their own savings, without making any "noise"?  Maybe they have and we just don't know about it.  Do they have to let you know so that you will stop your accusation?

And by the slightest chance, I hope you're not suggesting people to go line up at HSBC for a $40 134A donation

My best friend is a shop owner who happens to run a charity sales for the earthquake struck Xichang.  He is involve in volunteer work and charity work long before the earthquake.  I think what he's doing is great, I admire his patient as a business owner to put up with people pointing fingers when all his intension was to help people.